Name: Return to Amish
Description: Members of the original Breaking Amish cast along with new Amish cast members navigate life balancing their Amish values and community with new world freedoms.

Members of the original Breaking Amish cast along with new Amish cast members navigate life balancing their Amish values and community with new world freedoms.

Mary's husband is in for a rude awakening and Andrew has a score to settle.

Home is Where the Beef Is

Mary tries to get past her troubles in New York with some big experiences.

Shunned and the City

Mary argues with Chester about the church, and Chapel gets some news.

I'm Amish, What Are You?

Chapel gets heartbreaking news and must figure out how to tell Andrew.

Six More Weeks of Winter

A major decision is made in Andy and Chapel's relationship.

Brother, Where Art Thou?

Jeremiah makes the most difficult decision of his life.

Rebel Without a Clue

Andrew and Chapel prepare for their big day, but nothing runs smoothly.

Second Chances

The cast reunites to discuss new babies, old rivalries and more.

The Shunning Truth

Kate makes a change to her looks that could affect her modeling career.

Broken Family

The group overhauls an old house in hopes of creating a bed and breakfast.

Under Arrest

Everyone waits for news on Mary, and Kate rushes to be by her side.

A Real Emergency

Mary gets unexpected guests and puts them through a real Amish experience.

Mother Schmucker's B&B

Kate and Rebecca help Mary get healthier, and Katie Ann makes a decision.

Other Side of the Fence

Abe and Rebecca discover a secret Jeremiah has been hiding.

A Secret

The church pressures Mary to shut down the bed and breakfast.

Ultimatum

Mary visits Kate in New York and gets a bit more than she bargained for.

Big Decisions

Everyone supports Mary during a crisis and helps her with a new start.

Judgment Day

The whole gang takes a road trip to New York City to surprise Kate.

Banished

Abe must decide if the cost of dental work is worth compromising beliefs.

Dental Dilemma

Esther makes a deal with Mary to experience English life.

You Lie!

Mary makes an Amish meal to bring everyone together and make peace.

Breaking Dad

The cast returns to Lancaster to celebrate Amish Old Christmas with Mary.

Rebels Without a Claus

Mary must decide her fate and Jeremiah makes a life-changing announcement.

The Announcement

The cast travels to Jeremiah's wedding and meets his fiancee.

License to Wed

Sabrina faces a new custody battle while coping with her pregnancy.

Mary With Children

Jeremiah and Carmela's marriage is tested when they become homeowners.

I Got You Abe

Rebecca's arrival in Florida creates upheaval for everyone's vacation.

Fun in the Shun

Jeremiah and Carmela meet an IVF specialist and Sabrina goes into labor.

From Here to Maternity

Mary supports Sabrina at a custody hearing for her newborn baby.

Chasing Raber

Mary takes Jeremiah and Carmela on the honeymoon they never had.

Amish Pair-o-Dice

The journey of a young Amish girl's journey to being a young wife and mom.

Rebecca's Story

New interviews are conducted with people who know Mary Schmucker best.

Mary's Story

Sabrina and her castmates document her quest after leaving the Mennonites.

Sabrina's Story

Interviews document a man's journey from an Amish to an English man.

Abe's Story

Andrew, Esther and Katie Ann's journey's are chronicled through insights.

Return to Amish

More Like This